As technological advancements accelerate, particularly in robotics and artificial intelligence (AI), Canada is faced with an important question: What will the future of work look like for its citizens? The traditional model of employment, already eroding in certain sectors, may soon be a relic as machines perform tasks faster, cheaper, and more efficiently than humans. But rather than fearing the future, Canada can take a bold step forward—one that ensures economic security for all: Universal Basic Income (UBI).
The Lindsay, Ontario Pilot: A Missed Opportunity
The idea of UBI isn’t hypothetical in Canada; it was already put into practice in a three-year pilot in Lindsay, Ontario, launched in 2017. The experiment aimed to test whether a basic income could improve quality of life, reduce poverty, and empower individuals to find meaningful work or pursue education. Sadly, this promising pilot was canceled after just one year by the Ontario government, leaving many wondering what could have been. https://lindsayadvocate.ca/transforming-lives-insights-from-the-ontario-basic-income-pilot-program-in-lindsay/
But the conversation doesn’t stop with Lindsay. It’s time to revisit UBI not as an isolated test, but as a potential solution to Canada's growing socio-economic issues.
Administrative Overhead: A Burden We Can Reimagine
Currently, Canada spends billions on administering a labyrinth of social assistance programs: Ontario Disability Support Program (ODSP), provincial welfare programs, subsidized housing, and more. The resources allocated to manage, monitor, and, "police" these programs are staggering. Add to this the complexity of eligibility requirements, the stigmatization of recipients, and inefficiencies in distributing support, and the system begins to feel both cumbersome and ineffective.
Imagine instead if much of this administrative burden could be reduced by streamlining these programs into one universal safety net—UBI. By repurposing the funds spent on bureaucracy and enforcement, a significant portion of the budget could be allocated toward providing every Canadian a stable income floor.
A More Humane Approach to Vulnerability
But UBI is not just about redistributing financial resources; it’s also about changing the way we think about support for vulnerable populations. Rather than forcing individuals to prove their worthiness for aid, UBI offers dignity by providing unconditional support. This could free up resources to focus on genuine mental health and rehabilitation services, for those who need specialized assistance beyond just financial support.
By disentangling financial aid from bureaucratic surveillance, we could better allocate resources to improving public healthcare, mental health services, and other critical areas where funds are often scarce.
Addressing Food Insecurity and Poverty
According to Statistics Canada, close to 1 in 10 (9.9%) Canadians were living in poverty and 16.9% of Canadians were food insecure in 2022, with those numbers being even higher in particularly vulnerable segments of the population and in certain provinces. https://www.statcan.gc.ca/o1/en/plus/6257-canadians-are-facing-higher-levels-food-insecurity. Existing responses to this have been employment and increasing minimum wages, emergency food programs (food banks), social assistance, and a myriad of local, provincial, and federal government and not-for-profit initiatives, all incurring high costs for administration and varying levels of policing... a patchwork quilt of "remedies" that make it difficult for individuals and families to access when it is needed, yet would be a non-issue with a UBI.
The Technological Tipping Point
The disruption caused by AI, automation, and robotics cannot be understated. The reality is that many jobs, especially in manufacturing, retail, services, and even knowledge sectors, are at risk. Rather than reactively dealing with the fallout through band-aid programs, UBI offers a proactive solution. With a stable income, Canadians would be free to retrain, pursue education, or even explore entrepreneurial ventures without the constant fear of financial collapse. "AI could replace equivalent of 300 million jobs" https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-65102150
It is no longer about if technology will upend traditional employment structures—it’s about when. Canada has an opportunity to be a global leader by preparing for that future now.
In Conclusion: A Potential Path Forward for Canada
UBI is not a panacea, nor does it claim to be. It is, however, a bold albeit highly debated and contentious idea that may very well align with the realities of a rapidly changing world. By addressing not just poverty and food insecurity, but the instability brought about by technological disruption, UBI offers a lifeline to all Canadians—whether or not they are among today's vulnerable populations. And by simplifying the social safety net, we can free up resources to build a healthier, more resilient society.
The time to rethink our approach to work, social support, and a potential model for a Universal Basic Income is now.
Comments